• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Hanover Pizza & Ice Cream Unlimited: Experience the Best Pizza and Ice Cream in Newark, OH

Hanover Pizza & Ice Cream Unlimited is a beloved gem in Newark, Ohio, known for its vibrant community spirit and delicious offerings. With signature pizzas like AllTheWay, Chicken Bacon Ranch, and Meat Lovers, each dish is crafted to perfection. Weaving nostalgia and flavor, customers rave about the incredible garlic crust pizza and family-friendly atmosphere. The friendly staff and ownership foster a homey vibe that keeps patrons returning year after year. Whether you’re indulging in their Philly Cheese Steak or savoring the delightful Garlic Cheese Bread, Hanover Pizza delivers not just food, but a heartfelt experience that satisfies every craving.

Hanover Pizza & Ice Cream Unlimited at a glance

  • Address 2255 W High St NE, Newark, OH 43055
  • Phone (740) 763-4561
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for dinner .

Photos & Gallery

Hanover Pizza & Ice Cream Unlimited: Reviews & Ratings

Jordan Estep
5

I'll tell you what this is the best Hometown Pizza around! Great people in a family in business multiple Generations! If you haven't tried it you need to!

Bill Tudor
5

Been ordering from Hanover Pizza for a while. Food is always fresh and hot. You're greeted pretty soon after entering and taken care of to pay. Ordering is always easy and they've never made a mistake in our orders. Great pizza from a small business!

Cortney Deckard
5

The garlic crust pizza is amazing. I also love the BLT sub (add pizza sauce). I have been going there for almost 10 years now and it has always been delicious. The staff are so kind and I remember the owners being so friendly. They really make this town feel like home.

Josh Chapin
5

They were so generous on their toppings! Crust was thin and chewy - they even ask if you want garlic butter on the crust... Yes please! My mouth is watering as i think about it again

John Elk
4

they're okay pizza, although i live too far away to get it regularly. i recommend the meatball sub if you stop by, icecream isn't bad either (when they have it lol)

Kaitlynn Curtis
5

Such a family friendly environment! My husband and I love their pizza, especially with the garlic crust. The kids are over the moon about their ice cream and garlic bread! Best in the valley!

EFFICIENT MOVING
4

Good pizza if you're out this way. Order it well done/crispy for a proper cook. Pepperoni is great, sauce is tangy and savory, crust is good when ordered as above.

Stephen Burch
4

Hanover pizza is a delicious and solid local small town pizza joint. Absolutely worth the try! We got the classic pep & ham as well as their Chicken Bacon Ranch. What really impressed me was their crust which was a rich bready crust. The sauce is one of the lighter in Licking County but well created, a rich seasoned flavor with a hint of sweetness. The CBR pizza was also quite delicious especially with the provided ranch drizzled on top which would be my overall recommendation for any user- drizzle the ranch or ask for heavy sauce. I would also keep in mind that the CBR pizza has large pieces of lettuce, if not your thing an Overall really cool spot which we will be returning to for years, thanks!

Location

  • Hanover Pizza & Ice Cream Unlimited
    Hanover Pizza & Ice Cream Unlimited
    2255 W High St NE, Newark, OH 43055 Hotline: (740) 763-4561

Welcome to Hanover Pizza & Ice Cream Unlimited, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Newark, Ohio. Located at 2255 W High St NE, this family-run establishment has been serving up delicious, hearty pizzas and delightful ice cream concoctions, making it a beloved local spot for nearly a decade. With a commitment to providing quality food and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, Hanover Pizza stands out as a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts.

As you step into Hanover Pizza, you're greeted not just by the intoxicating aroma of fresh pizza but also by friendly faces ready to serve you. Customer reviews echo a sense of community here. One reviewer, zwan1978, declared their first visit "worth the drive," concluding that it was the best pizza they'd had in a long time. Similarly, Cortney Deckard praised the amazing garlic crust pizza and highlighted the friendly staff, noting how the owners really make the town feel like home.

Hanover Pizza & Ice Cream Unlimited features a lineup of signature pizzas that are sure to tantalize any palate. Among the favorites are:

  • AllTheWay - For those who want it all in one bite.
  • Hanover House - A classic that captures the essence of flavor.
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch - A savory blend that delights every time.
  • Meat Lovers - A hearty option for the meat aficionado.

In addition to their stellar pizzas, Hanover Pizza offers a range of mouthwatering options such as the Philly Cheese Steak, BLT sub with pizza sauce, and even garlic cheese bread that perfectly complements any meal. Each dish is crafted with the utmost care, using quality ingredients to ensure a memorable dining experience.

The multitiered reputation of Hanover Pizza has been built through decades of hard work and dedication, as echoed by customers like Jordan Estep, who remarked on the great people behind this family business spanning multiple generations. And kris shell noted, "This is really great pizza!" A sentiment sure to resonate with anyone who tries it.

Overall, Hanover Pizza & Ice Cream Unlimited isn't just a pizzeria; it's a community hub where flavors flourish and family traditions blend. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or an adventurous combo, Hanover Pizza promises satisfying meals that will keep you coming back for more. Don't miss out on what many locals hail as the best hometown pizza around!

For a delightful dining experience or a quick takeout option, contact them at (740) 763-4561 and prepare to be amazed!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • Has drive-through
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards